NESN Playground

NESN Community

Welcome to NESN Community Sign in | Join | Help
in
Home Playground Blog Center Message Boards Image Galleries Live Chat Polls Mailbag Contests RSS Feeds
Visit the Playground homepageNESN University blog homepage

NESN U

  • Offensive talent to watch

    Things you probably won't overhear in New England’s fall sports season:

    "Hey, how about that Colonial Athletic Conference? Man, UNH and Maine sure are taking it down to the wire! I wonder if either has a legitimate shot at a Football Champion Subdivision playoff berth."

    Or …

    "Jeez, if only Darius Butler didn't hurt himself. UConn’s secondary lost a big playmaker. That’s for sure!"

    And I haven't heard anyone on local talk radio say …

    "All everyone talks about is B.J. Raji. It's B.J. Raji this, and B.J. Raji that. What about Ron Brace? That guy is the heart and soul of the Eagles' defense, not to mention Brian Toal. And don’t even get me started on Kevin Akins."

    The truth is that college football doesn't just take a backseat in New England. It's more of a moped on the region's busy athletic road.

    That said, there is some serious talent playing cold-weather football in the college ranks in frosty New England this season. With the regular season(s) winding down -- some are already complete -- let's take a well-deserved look at the region's top talent on the college gridiron. Part one will focus on the offense. I'll follow up with my defensive picks, and my special teams players in the coming days.

    Best quarterback
    Chris Pizzotti, Harvard, senior
    In nine games this season, Pizzotti has completed 63 percent of his passes for 2,381 yards and thrown 17 touchdowns to just four interceptions. He leads the Ivy League and ranks high nationally as well. The quarterback is 11th in the nation with a 149.51 passer efficiency rating, ninth in total offense, 13th in passing yards per game (265), 23rd in completions per game (20) and 24th in total passing yards.

    The Reading, Mass., native was also named to the list of Walter Payton Award finalists, as one of the top 16 players in Div. I-AA, er … the Football Championship Subdivision. Pizzotti (6-foot-5, 225 pounds) is fast becoming a top NFL prospect after his brilliant season. Can he make it at the next level despite being an Ivy Leaguer with only one full season as a starter under his belt? (He did pass for 2,134 yards last season, throwing 14 touchdowns in nine games.)

    Former Crimson quarterback Ryan Fitzpatrick and Joe Flacco of Delaware are currently starting in the NFL. Fitzpatrick is leading the Cincinnati Bengals, while Flacco has been solid as the Ravens' signal-caller in his rookie season.

    Honorable mention
    Liam Coen, UMass, senior
    Coen is the finest quarterback in Minuteman history and owns 30 school records.

    Chris Crane, Boston College, senior
    Crane stepped into Matt Ryan's huge shoes and has been solid, if not spectacular, in the tough ACC. He threw for 428 yards and two touchdowns in the Oct. 4 win at N.C. State, but has tossed 13 picks against 10 touchdowns this season.

    Best running back
    Donald Brown, UConn, junior
    This isn’t even close. Brown is the best running back to play at a New England  college/university since William Green broke records at BC from 1998 to 2000. Brown's 1,500-plus rushing yards and 16 touchdowns have made the 5-foot-10, 210-pounder a Maxwell Award finalist (nation’s top offensive player). But even he realizes the unlikelihood that a kid from UConn could wrestle one of the sport’s major awards from the Tim Tebows of the world.

    "I think, eventually, down the line, the chances of that happening will increase as we start getting more respect around the country," Brown said. "Right now, we don't get much respect outside of this building."

    With remaining games against South Florida and Pittsburgh, Brown is expected to eclipse 1,800 yards on the ground and will likely become the Huskies' all-time leading rusher this weekend. Going into these games, Brown leads the nation with 153.7 rushing yards per game.

    Honorable mention
    Tony Nelson, UMass, junior
    He’s the CAA’s only 1,000 yard rusher this season and has 10 touchdowns with one more game to play. The UMass ground game hardly misses the legendary Steve Baylark, who recently worked out for Mike Shanahan's Broncos.

    Deron Brown, MIT, junior
    Yes, they have a football team. Yes, this guy makes my list over other notables like Northeastern bulldozer Alex Broomfield. I don’t care who he played against. Brown rushed for 1,816 yards and 22 touchdownss for the Engineers this season. I’m willing to wager he’s the only player with a double major in electrical engineering and computer sciences on this list.

    Best wide receiver
    Victor Cruz, UMass, junior

    This is a thin crop. I’m going with Cruz, the only player in the CAA with 1,000 receiving yards. He also has 16 touchdowns, which is a gaudy number in this conference, even if you are catching passes from Liam Coen. Cruz is a nice player, but like all other receivers in New England, probably won’t be paid to play at the next level, especially at 5-foot-11.

    Honorable mentions: Did I mention this was a thin crop?
    Bobby Sewall, Brown, senior
    Sewall has hauled in 63 catches for the Bears this season. His 72 points leads the league. He’s a native of Portsmouth, R.I. He's no Sean Morey, but few are.

    David Benoit, Westfield State, junior
    A Division-III player. I know nothing about this guy, but he deserves props for a season in which he posted 65 receptions, 1,046 yards and 16 touchdowns. A 16-touchdown season is an accomplishment at any level.

    Best tight end
    Ryan Purvis, BC, senior
    Nobody felt the effects of Matt Ryan’s departure like Purvis. Last year, the 6-foot-4, 260-pounder caught 54 passes for 553 yards and four touchdowns, and was subsequently named to the 2008 John Mackey Award watch list.

    This season, he has spent more time protecting Chris Crane than catching passes from him -- his 19 grabs are the lowest output since his freshman year. While he hasn’t caught a touchdown this season, he’s still considered a top talent. Count on him catching on as a rookie free agent with an NFL team in 2009 if he isn’t scooped up late in the draft.

    Best offensive lineman
    William Beatty, UConn, junior, left tackle
    At 6-foot-6 and listed at 310 pounds (he may be bigger), the monstrous, yet athletic Beatty (pronounced Bee-Tee) is drawing NFL interest. After springing Donald Brown all season, Beatty looks to be a late-round draft pick this April with a solid combine showing. Along with BC's solid senior guard Cliff Ramsey, Beatty is one of the few offensive linemen prospects playing in New England who have an NFL chance.

    As mentioned, two other installments of New England’s top college players will follow (defense, special teams). Feel free to leave comments and opinions.

  • ACC title game within reach

    As I watched the games Saturday, I really thought there would be a big upset. Several teams struggled, but they all pulled it out in the end.

    Alabama led Mississippi State at halftime based solely on its special teams. The Crimson Tide pulled away in the second half. USC was tied with Stanford at the half as the Cardinals ran all over USC’s defense. The Trojans also put the game away in the second half. For the second week in a row, Georgia had to come from behind in the fourth quarter against an average SEC foe, but they also were able to secure a victory.

    Finally, we have LSU, which trailed Troy 31-3 in the third quarter. Nevertheless, on the wings of a 30 point fourth quarter, even the Tigers were able to avoid the upset.

    So, since all the top teams managed to win this week, my main story is the ACC. It is true that the conference does not boast a national title contender. However, what the conference lacks in top-heavy power, they make up for in overall competitive play. This makes the ACC very exciting to watch. While only three teams (Maryland and Boston College in the Atlantic Division and Miami in the Coastal Division) control their destiny, I would not bet that any of those three will be in the ACC title game.

    Want numbers? Check these out. With two weeks to play, 11 of the 12 teams in the ACC are separated by two games or less, with Duke the one exception. Nine of the 12 teams are still mathematically alive to play in the ACC championship game. Six of the 12 teams are ranked between 23 and 29 in the latest USA Today poll. Nine of the 12 teams average between 300-350 yards per game and another nine of the 12 teams average between 20-28 points per game.

    All right, you get the point. As you can imagine, these statistics have translated into some extremely competitive football on the field. I agree that the ACC does not have a dominant team, and they may not even deserve an automatic BCS bid. However, as I fan, I love it. Would you rather watch one team beat everyone into submission? Not me. I like to watch games that can truly go either way. That’s excitement.

    Games of the week
    No. 24 South Carolina 6
    No. 3 Florida 56
    Odd note: This game marked the first time a Heisman Trophy winner (Steve Spurrier) has ever been a head coach against another trophy recipient (Tim Tebow).

    In the first quarter, South Carolina turned the ball over three times over the span of four plays. This led to a 21-0 deficit. From that point, the rout was on. Florida dominated this game, demonstrated by the fact that they had an impressive 519-173 advantage in total yards. When it was all said and done, the Gators handed Spurrier his worst loss ever. I’m pretty sure no one will be shedding a tear for the ol’ ball coach.

    Florida has looked terrific lately. After clinching a spot in the SEC championship game last week, I wanted to see how it would come out against South Carolina. Boy, the Gators sure didn’t disappoint. Tebow is in Heisman form, and the defense is playing lights out. The Gators are fifth in the country in scoring offense (44.1 ppg) and fourth in scoring defense (11.3 ppg). I haven’t seen numbers that good since my Madden ’05 season with the Pats.

    No. 17 North Carolina 15
    Maryland 17

    Since Miami beat Virginia Tech last Thursday, UNC entered this game in control of its own destiny in the ACC. Unfortunately for them, Maryland wasn’t about to give them anything, and the Tar Heels were not strong enough to take it. A first half played in severe rain resulted in a 15-14 North Carolina lead. The second-half weather was much better, but so where the defenses. Both teams combined for only 239 yards, with seven punts, two turnovers, and a measly three points in the second half. In the defining drive, a stagnant Maryland offense came alive and marched 73 yards before kicking a go-ahead field goal.
     
    This season, Maryland is 6-0 at home and 1-3 on the road. They have beaten four ranked teams at home, but lost to Virginia and Middle Tennessee State on the road. The fact is, college teams often play considerably better at home. But no matter how the Terrapins got here, Maryland is in control of its destiny in terms of the ACC. If both Maryland and Boston College win next week, then Maryland and BC will play in the regular-season finale, with the winner going to the ACC championship game. Oh, and the game is at The Heights.

    I told you that North Carolina is the best team in the ACC when quarterbacked by a healthy T.J. Yates. This was the first week in nearly two months that Yates was healthy, so I expected good things. Inexplicably, UNC coach Butch Davis stuck with junior Cameron Sexton as opposed to starting Yates. This is not like the Patriots, when Drew Bledsoe lost his starting job, while hurt, to Tom Brady. In this case, T.J. Yates is a much better quarterback than Sexton.

    Boston College 27
    No. 20 Florida State 17

    The Eagles jumped out to a quick 14-0 lead and held on for the win. As usual, Boston College’s defense was stout, allowing only 285 yards and forcing three turnovers. BC put the game away with a fourth-quarter drive that resulted in a field goal. On the drive, the Eagles rushed 15 consecutive times and ate up almost nine minutes of clock. All of the runs were by either Montel Harris (121 yards) or quarterback Chris Crane. When Florida State finally got the ball back, there was just not enough time to do anything.

    Florida State still has a chance to win the ACC Atlantic Division, but it now needs some help. Like so many of these ACC teams, the Seminoles are inconsistent. On paper, they are very good, with an average scoring margin of plus-14 points. They also rank fifth in the nation in total defense, allowing only 275 yards per game. The main problem is penalties, where they average eight penalties for over 75 yards per game. Some very talented teams, such as Florida and USC, can get away with committing a lot of penalties, but the Seminoles are not one of those teams. I really think that if Florida State committed fewer penalties, it would be a solid top 15 team.

    Boston College’s defense has looked amazing the last two weeks. If the Eagles win their final two games, at Wake Forest and home against Maryland, they will be playing in the ACC championship game. That would be an amazing feat for a team no one expected to challenge in the ACC. Their fate rests on the arm of Crane, who has been sporadic at best this season. He really needs to put together two good games for the Eagles to have a chance to play for a BCS game.

    California 21
    No. 23 Oregon State 34

    Oregon State led the majority of the game, but it was close throughout. The Beavers finally sealed the victory with a pick six in the fourth quarter. Oregon State’s defense was particularly solid in the game. Of Cal’s 15 possessions, only one of them lasted more than five plays. Oregon State also saw the return of starting quarterback Lyle Moevao. While Moevao didn’t have a good day passing, his return is important as the Beavers look to capture the Pac-10 title.

    With their win over USC earlier this year, Oregon State is the only team in the Pac-10 who controls its own destiny and the Rose Bowl berth that accompanies it. The Beavers' final two games are on the road against Arizona and at home against Oregon. These are two tough games, but Oregon State should be favored in both of them. I would love it if the Beavers' Rose Bowl life was at stake the final week of the season against Oregon, where the in-state rivalry is referred to as the "Civil War."

    Play of the week
    In the Vanderbilt-Kentucky game, Vanderbilt held an incredible 39-21 minute advantage in time of possession. One of the main reasons for this was the play(s) of the week: Kentucky roughing the punter. The Wildcats committed three personal fouls for roughing the punter in this game.

    I love when a team tries to block a punt, and obviously, if you constantly try to block punts, you will commit a few personal fouls -- this comes with the territory. But three roughing the punter fouls in one game is ridiculous. You are literally giving your opponent new life right after you stopped them. You cannot possibly expect to win games by sending a tired defense back onto the field to try and stop an offense they just stopped moments earlier.

    Things we learned this week
    • The ACC is still completely up for grabs.
    • Cincinnati controls its own destiny in the Big East.
    • Alabama is capable of winning in spite of its offensive deficiencies.
    • Oregon State still has a chance to spoil USC’s Rose Bowl hopes.

    Closing thoughts
    One of the reasons why college football is so great are the rivalry games. In addition to the normal excitement that surrounds rivalry games, several college football games stoke the competitive fire by playing for a tangible trophy. The fans and teams go crazy for these games. How crazy you ask? Well, check out this bonfire before a Texas-Texas A&M game.

    But wait, I haven’t even gotten to the best part, which is the actual trophy. Some of these trophies are ordinary, run-of-the mill types that you see all the time. But some are truly unique. Below is a list of my ten favorite college football rivalry trophies.

    10. Oregon and Oregon State
    Trophy: Platypus Trophy
    History: This inter-state rivalry game is referred to as the “Civil War.” In 1959, Oregon created a trophy featuring a platypus to be held by the reigning champion. They chose a platypus because of the schools' mascots (Oregon Ducks and Oregon State Beavers). A platypus has the bill of a duck and the tail of a beaver. The actual trophy was missing between 1961 and 2004, but it was found and is once again presented to the winner.

    9. Boise State and Fresno State
    Trophy: A 10-gallon chrome Milk Can
    History: California and Idaho are two of the nation’s top four states in terms of dairy production. In 2005, one dairy group from each state decided to put up money and a trophy for the victory of this game. This is the only traveling trophy among WAC schools.

    8. Iowa State and Missouri
    Trophy: Telephone Trophy
    History: Before the 1959 game, it was discovered that the coaches’ field phones somehow had switched wires. While testing, they realized that each sideline could hear the other. The problem was fixed before the start of the game, but the Northwestern Bell Telephone Company created the trophy after the controversy.

    7. Minnesota and Wisconsin
    Trophy: Paul Bunyan’s Axe
    History: Originally these two teams played for a wooden Slab of Bacon. It was created to symbolize the winning team "bringing home the bacon." When the wooden piece of meat went missing, they modified the tradition by playing for a large wooden axe, referred to as Paul Bunyan's Axe.

    6. Michigan State and Penn State
    Trophy: Land Grant Trophy
    History: This trophy is given because these are two of the nation’s oldest land-grant colleges, where the government donated land to be used for higher learning. The trophy itself is pretty boring, but the idea of giving a Land Grant trophy just sounds cool.

    5. Cincinnati and Louisville
    Trophy: Keg of Nails
    History: It is not known for sure exactly how this tradition started. However, it does have a long history, extending over three conferences, as Cincinnati and Louisville moved from the Missouri Valley Conference, to Conference USA, to the Big East. The current trophy is a replica of a keg used to transport nails. It signifies that the winning team is "tough as nails."

    4. Indiana and Michigan State
    Trophy: The Old Brass Spittoon
    History: The trophy was initiated by the Michigan State student council in 1950. The spittoon came from one of Michigan's earliest trading posts and is believed to be nearly 190 years old. According to legend, this exact spittoon was around when both institutions were founded -- Indiana in 1820 and MSU in 1855.

    3. Mississippi and Mississippi State
    Trophy: Golden Egg
    History: In 1926, after a Mississippi victory, its fans rushed the field to try and tear down the goalposts. Mississippi State (Mississippi A&M at the time) fans then ran onto the field to defend its goalposts. Fights broke out resulting in several injuries. From that point on, the schools decided to award a trophy to the victorious team as a way to help prevent on-field celebrations by fans. The trophy was designed to be a brass football on top of a wooden base. However, since footballs in the 1920s were more oval than round, the trophy resembles a golden-colored egg.

    2. Illinois and Ohio State
    Trophy: A wooden turtle, called an Illibuck
    History: The tradition began in 1925 and used a live turtle. Yes, the schools actually passed a living animal back and forth. The turtle, a creature with a very long life expectancy, was meant to symbolize long life for the rivalry. When the turtle passed away, the teams began using wooden turtles, and they write the scores on the shell. They are currently on their ninth wooden turtle. During the second half of each game, the trophy is passed to the team that won the previous year’s game. The passing is done in a bizarre ritual among students, where the Illibuck is passed overhead and backward.

    1. Iowa and Minnesota
    Trophy: Floyd of Rosedale
    History: The tradition started in 1935, as a bet between Iowa and Minnesota governors to try and relieve some of the postgame fighting between the fans. The first trophy was a live pig. After that game, a bronze trophy was created in its likeness.

  • No title for Joe Pa

     

    I usually break down the top games in order of team rank. This week, I will be providing insight in chronological order of the games.

    Games of the week:
    No. 10 Utah 13
    No. 11 TCU 10
    My week started out on Thursday night, as college football had a BCS-buster game between TCU and Utah. Unfortunately, this game was broadcast on CBS College Sports, channel 261 on local Comcast, so most people couldn’t watch it, even if they wanted. This list includes me. So, I went to The Lazy Dog Sports Bar in Marlborough to watch the game on DirecTV.

    Since everyone I knew was busy, I had to go alone. If you have never watched a game alone in a bar, I do not recommend it -- it’s pretty awkward. For one thing, the waitress kept eyeing me, probably waiting for me to bolt without paying my bill. Also, I was taking notes while everyone around me was acting like you should on a Thirsty Thursday, probably wondering what this creepy guy was doing. I felt like Jim Halpert watching Michael Scott at the Dundies.

    And now on to the game. TCU has a terrific defense, led by defensive coordinator Dick Bumpas. Can you think of a better name for a football coach? In this game, the Bumpas-led Horned Frogs defense terrorized Utah quarterback Brian Johnson all night. Luckily for Utah, its defense was up to the challenge. After allowing 10 points on TCU’s first two possessions, Utah shut them out the rest of the way. In the end, Utah was able to make just enough plays to put together a touchdown drive with two minutes to play, and that was enough to squeak out a win.

    Utah is now firmly in control of its own BCS destiny. They have two games left, only one of which is against a good team, BYU. If they win out, they will be headed for a BCS game. Otherwise, Boise State looks primed to take its place.

    No. 19 North Carolina 28
    No. 22 Georgia Tech 7
    At Georgia Tech, former Navy coach Paul Johnson has brought the triple option back to big-time college football. I love this. One of my favorite aspects of college football is all the different offensive and defensive systems that teams run. It is always exciting to watch a team run the triple option. Tech still has a ways to go, but they look very good for Year 1 of this offense.

    The story of this game was North Carolina’s defense. They contained Georgia Tech’s triple option offense and forced three turnovers. Next week, North Carolina expects to see the full- time return of its first-string quarterback, T.J. Yates. When Yates is at full speed, North Carolina is the best team in the ACC.

    Announcer note: In the first half of the Ohio State-Northwestern game, Ohio State faced a third down in Northwestern’s territory. If Northwestern stopped them, Ohio State would probably settle for a field goal attempt.

    Before the play, announcer and former standout college quarterback Andre Ware said, “If Northwestern can stop Ohio State here, it would be a major, major, minor victory for the defense.” Right now, you are probably feeling the same way I was -- confused. Don’t look to me for answers. I’m just telling you what he said.

    No. 14 Georgia 42
    Kentucky 38

    Georgia’s offense was terrific in this game, but its defense was awful. Kentucky entered the game averaging only 14 points per game in SEC play, but scored at least one touchdown in every quarter to come this close to pulling off a major upset. Georgia threw an 11-yard, jump-ball touchdown pass with under two minutes to play for the victory. It was a terrific catch by Georgia freshman wideout A.J. Green, who had to outleap three Kentucky defensive backs to make the grab.

    I am starting to get the feeling that Georgia is missing something this year. Talent-wise, this should have been a blowout. The Bulldogs are just an inconsistent team. One reason is that they are undisciplined. Georgia is second-to-last in the country in penalties per game. Even with more talent, it is difficult to consistently win when you are giving away free yardage.

    Iowa 24
    No. 3 Penn State 23
    And everything is right is in the world again. No team from the Big Ten deserves to play for a national championship, and now no team will. That is not an indictment against Penn State, but more so against the Big Ten in general. The SEC and Big 12 are the two best conferences, and it will be a shame if their champions do not play in the title game.

    I was flipping back and forth between this game and the Alabama-LSU game, and this one did not have my full attention. However, what I did see was not pretty. I guess that is Big Ten football. It is fun to watch a whole game, but just catching a few plays is boring. Penn State led for the majority of the game, but never looked in control. Its running game was good, but quarterback Daryll Clark was abysmal, completing just 9-of-23 passes for 89 yards. He also threw a big interception in the fourth quarter. Penn State must now regroup and win its final two games in order to capture the Big Ten title. I hope they do, but I am also glad they lost this one.

    There is no other way to say it, Penn State choked. Even on the road, they should never have lost to this Iowa team. This wasn’t an Iron Mike-Buster Douglas choke, but it is one that will stick with Joe Pa for a while.
     
    No. 1 Alabama 27
    No. 15 LSU 21
    The story of the week was Nick Saban returning to LSU. Four years ago, Saban resigned as coach of LSU to coach the Miami Dolphins. At that time, LSU fans were happy for him. However, Saban quit the Miami job after two seasons and then returned to the SEC to coach Alabama, LSU’s biggest rival. As you might expect, LSU fans were more than a little upset. Imagine if Bill Belichick retired and then returned two years later to coach the Jets. It’s like a slap in the face.

    Personally, I wanted Saban to take it to the next level. I hoped he would run onto the field in a yellow LSU T-shirt. Then, while in the middle of the field, he could pull a Hollywood Hulk Hogan. You know, tear the shirt to pieces and put his hand to his ear. Much to my dismay, Saban decided to forgo this introduction and act more professionally. Oh, well, maybe next time.

    On the field it was a great, albeit sloppy, game. The offenses moved the ball, but both defenses controlled the game. The attacking defenses forced a total of seven turnovers. As Walter Sobchak from "The Big Lebowski" would say, LSU freshman quarterback Jarrett Lee was out of his element. He might be ready for this game next year, but this week, his inexperience showed. Lee threw four interceptions, and had several others passes that could have been picked off.

    Alabama is a tough one to figure out. While its defense is terrific, I have serious concerns about how well its offense can perform in big games. Personally, I do not think that senior quarterback John Parker Wilson will be able to step up when he needs to. I guess we will find out for sure in the SEC championship game, since Florida and Alabama have already set that date by winning their divisions.

    Boston College–Notre Dame update: With four top 10 teams in action at 8 p.m. on Saturday, BC-ND wasn’t exactly high on my priority list. However, I did flip over a few times to check the score. My only real thought was, wow, Charlie Weiss put most of that weight back on. He looked like Tom Brady first-Superbowl big. He isn’t quite back to Patriots dynasty big, but he is getting there.

    No. 2 Texas Tech 56
    No. 8 Oklahoma State 20
    This game reminded me of Rocky’s first fight with Clubber Lang when Lang knocked him out in the second round. When asked for a prediction before the fight, Clubber Lang responded, “My prediction? Pain.”

    And pain is exactly what Oklahoma State felt.

    After knocking off undefeated Texas last week, I was wondering what Texas Tech would do for an encore. Well, you don’t have to worry about the Red Raiders. They are just fine. 

    Tech turned what was supposed to be a close game into a bloodbath, as they thrashed Oklahoma State. I could go on and on about how badly Oklahoma State got beat, but I will just say this: Texas Tech’s offense racked up over 600 yards and scored touchdowns on eight of its 10 drives.

    Next week, Tech visits Norman, Okla., to face the Sooners. Some say Oklahoma has the best offense in the country. Oh, it should be a good one.

    Tony Kornheiser note: During halftime of the Florida-Vanderbilt debacle, ESPN had a segment where the three Monday Night Football commentators discussed the upcoming game. I assume they were supposed to look “casual”, but Tony Kornheiser’s outfit was laughable. In addition to his normal comb over/mullet look, his outfit was highlighted by sunglasses and loafers without socks. Tony, you are on national television, put some socks on. It looked like he was auditioning for the next Miami Vice movie. Are these the type of people you want providing NFL insight?

    No. 7 USC 17
    No. 21 California 3
    The USC defense is just nasty. In this game, it gave up only 165 yards of offense. This number is especially impressive, considering that the USC offense was ineffective all night. Time after time, USC’s smothering defense forced Cal to punt.

    Against better teams, USC’s offense looks pretty pedestrian. Sure, they can hang 69 on Washington State, but they have trouble against even decent defenses. I think they are another example of a good, but not great team. They are in the same category with Georgia, Ohio State and Missouri, to name a few.

    Play of the week:
    Facing first-and-15 at its 45 with 14 minutes, 10 seconds remaining in the second quarter, Ohio State handed the ball off to running back Chris Wells. Wells ran almost straight ahead into a wall of defenders. A second later, there were nine defenders within five yards of Wells. I figured it was a three-yard loss for sure. Then, Wells pushed one defender to the ground and ran straight ahead, untouched, past eight men on his way to an amazing 55-yard touchdown run. This is why Northwestern is Northwestern, and Ohio State is Ohio State.

    Things we learned this week:
    • Texas Tech is that good.
    • We will not have to witness another Big Ten team play for a BCS title.
    • Oklahoma’s offense is legendary. Over the last three games, they have averaged 47 points … in the first half.
    • USC’s defense is unbelievable. Over the last 22 quarters, USC has given up a total of 13 points.

    Closing thoughts:
    I have heard a lot of talk lately about how stupid it is to fire college coaches during the season. I have to disagree with this criticism. Now, I think that some schools fire coaches too quickly, but that is an argument for another day. Right now ,I am simply focusing on when coaches get fired. The main reason that many coaches are fired during the season is to try and save as many incoming recruits as possible.

    There are several coaches who have already been fired this season, but I will use Tennessee as an example. By all accounts, Tennessee is said to have a top 10 incoming recruiting class. Tennessee is having a bad year this season, and the players with only verbal commitments could see this poor play and look to go elsewhere. By making the coaching change announcement now, the school is saying that it is committed to winning.

    If the Volunteers waited until after the season to announce the firing of Phillip Fulmer, the entire class is at jeopardy. Tennessee’s list of recruits includes nine four-star players. None of these nine players are from Tennessee, so there is nothing keeping them here. By announcing midseason that they will make a coaching change, the Vols are trying to minimize the number of recruits who rescind their acceptance.

    Changing coaches can lead to a painful transition. However, keeping bad coaches can bring about even worse results. When an athletic department decides it is time to make a change, I feel that a midseason announcement is the way to go.

  • Texas Tech is for real

    I did not think Texas Tech could beat Texas. Boy, was I wrong. Congratulations, Texas Tech, you now have my full attention. Tech’s victory over Texas propels them from a good team to a great team. Suddenly, the Red Raiders are the team to beat in the Big 12. 

    Under coach Mike Leach, Texas Tech could always score on anyone. However, the difference this season is that the team can actually play defense. Against Texas, they pressured Colt McCoy all night, sacking him four times and returning an interception for a touchdown.  After nine games, Texas Tech is ranked first in the Big 12 in total yards allowed per game and third in the Big 12 in points per game.

    The pollsters have also taken notice of the Red Raiders. In the AP Poll, Tech moved from No. 6 to No. 2, jumping undefeated Penn State. In the two human polls that matter in terms of the BCS, Texas Tech is ranked third. However, the computer polls have Tech ranked No. 1, tied with Alabama. 

    There are still a lot of games to play, but it is interesting that the computer polls favor two Big 12 teams (Texas and Texas Tech) over Penn State. However, as long as Penn State finishes undefeated, I would be surprised if they do not play in the BCS championship game.

    Games of the week

    No. 6 Texas Tech 39
    No. 1 Texas 33
    Wow, what a game. Texas Tech, buoyed by the largest crowd in the history of Jones A&T Stadium, toppled the invincible Texas Longhorns. Tech received the opening kickoff, but was forced to punt. Texas then took over at their own two-yard line. Their very first play was a run that resulted in a safety. At that point, the gauntlet was thrown.

    The Red Raiders did not completely dominate the game, but they were just a little better than the Longhorns in every facet. Most notable was the line play. Tech’s huge offensive line was up to the task and outplayed Texas' front seven. 

    Meanwhile, Tech's defensive line embarrassed Texas' offensive line. Tech rushed three or four men all night, but the Texas line simply could not keep them out of the backfield. As evidence, Texas quarterback Colt McCoy was sporting a bloody lip after the game.

    Texas entered the game with the Big 12's top-ranked defense in terms of total yards allowed and points allowed. I figured that Texas' defense would be able to slow down Tech enough so that the Longhorns could outscore the Red Raiders. 

    I was right about Texas' defense, which did a decent job of slowing down Tech's offense. However, the difference was Tech's defense. The Red Raiders rushed only three or four men and played zone for most of the game. Tech defensive backs were sitting on the short routes that Texas loves to throw, forcing the Longhorns out of their game.

    Right from the start, Texas could not match Tech’s energy. After the safety, Texas' second possession resulted in three dropped passes. The last of which was a would-be sixty-yard touchdown pass that slipped through Jordan Shipley's  hands. At halftime, total yardage was 326-108 in favor of Tech. A big third-quarter punt return for a touchdown jump-started Texas, but it was not enough.

    Every great game needs a great ending, and this game certainly had that. After being outplayed all game, Texas scored a touchdown with less than two minutes to play to take a one-point lead. Then, after several first downs, Tech faced first and ten at the Texas 28 with under thirty seconds to play. After scrambling out of the pocket, Tech quarterback Graham Harrell threw a pass that bounced off a Tech receiver and rebounded into the air. The ball, flying softly through the air, seemed destined for a game-ending interception. Remarkably, it went right through the arms of Texas freshman safety Blake Gideon. It will probably be the easiest interception chance he will have in his Texas career.

    In the end, this was a game Tech deserved to win. The Red Raiders outplayed and outhustled the Longhorns from the start. The next two weeks, Tech plays at home against Oklahoma State and on the road at Oklahoma. These two games will determine just how good this Texas Tech team really is. But on this night, in front of this crowd, there was no question that Tech could have beaten any team in the country.

    No. 5 Florida 49
    No. 8 Georgia 10

    The yearly battle between Florida and Georgia is known as "The World's Largest Outdoor Cocktail Party." It is played on a neutral site, in Jacksonville, Fla., where the Jaguars play.  This year's game was a battle for the top spot in the SEC East. 

    Florida also entered the game with some extra motivation. Last year, Georgia's entire team stormed the field in celebration of its first touchdown. Georgia's players danced and stomped in the end zone, while the Gators stood and watched in bewilderment. This drew the ire of the Gators, but also propelled the Bulldogs to victory.

    In this game, Florida was clearly the better team. However, the final score is deceiving. At halftime, Florida only led 14-3, and Georgia had three big miscues. The Bulldogs missed two field goals (37 and 27 yards) and committed a personal foul that negated a would-be interception. Georgia could not overcome these mistakes, and eventually fell apart in the second half.

    Georgia looks like a good team, but Florida looks like a great team. Besides their loss to Mississippi, Florida has blown out every other team its has faced. After halftime, Florida dominated Georgia, as quarterback Tim Tebow passed Emmitt Smith to become Florida's all-time leader in rushing touchdowns. If Florida keeps playing this well, it will set up a terrific matchup against Alabama in the SEC championship game.

    Arkansas 30
    No. 19 Tulsa 23
    Tulsa entered the game 8-0, but Arkansas is its only opponent all season from a big six conference. It is important to note that the Razorbacks are not a particularly good team.  They are currently 1-4 in the SEC. Tulsa came into the game with the nation's top-ranked offense in terms of total yards per game (620) and points per game (56). Arkansas' defense was allowing 32 points per game, last in the SEC.

    Looking at the numbers, it seems like Tulsa would run away with this one, but this game highlights the disparity between good and bad conferences. In this case, the best team from Conference USA lost to one of the worst teams from the SEC. 

    Tulsa's offense did put up 528 yards, but the Golden Hurricane could not cash in when it counted. In fact, they scored less than the average team who plays Arkansas. 

    Now, I am not trying to bash Conference USA. I am simply pointed out that an undefeated team from a lower conference is sometimes worse than a middle-of-the-pack team from a top-tier conference.

    Play of the week
    There is only one play I could possibly choose this week: the play that slayed the dragon.  With eight second to play, one timeout, and down one point, Texas Tech faced second and ten from the Texas 28-yard line. With their kicking game unreliable all season, Tech called one final pass play to try and improve its field position. Tech quarterback Graham Harrell threw a fade route to the team's best wide receiver, Michael Crabtree

    The Texas defense was in man-to-man coverage with safety help, but it was powerless to stop Tech. Crabtree caught the fade pass at the Texas five-yard line, between two defenders, and then tiptoed on the sideline into the end zone. He scored with one second remaining on the game clock. 

    It was an unbelievable and shocking ending to an incredible game. With only seconds to play, you expect a short pass to help your field goal kicker. You do not expect a touchdown pass that wins the game.

    Things we learned this week

  • Texas Tech is for real.
  • No one wants to step up and take control of the ACC.
  • Michigan was supposed to struggle this season, but I never thought the Wolverines would fall short of bowl eligibility (2-7) with three games still to play.  However, I am confident that, in time, coach Rich Rodriguez will turn Michigan into a winner.
  • Tulsa is not a Top 25 team.

    Closing thoughts
    Playing on the road in professional sports is tough, but it does not compare to college.  Winning on the road in college sports is what separates the good teams from the great teams. We saw evidence this week, as Texas Tech was able to draw energy from their feverish crowd in its upset of Texas. 

    Since 2000, FBS teams have a 23 percent higher winning percentage at home than on the road. This season's numbers emulate the data.  Among the six major conferences, teams have won 70 percent of their home games and only 45 percent of their away games.

    So, what are the reasons for this? For starters, in big-time college sports, the only friends you have on the road are your teammates and your band.  Everyone else is against you. The fans are against you, even the local hotel employees are against you. And these fans live for their teams, always wearing their colors and cheering like every game is life or death. In professional sports, fans don’t always go crazy for every game the way they do in college.

    Another reason why playing on the road is so difficult and fans are so rowdy is because of the bands. If fans are calming down, a quick song from the band will ignite them every time.  If you haven’t been to a big-time college football game, then you cannot appreciate just how much impact these big bands have on the fans.

    One additional factor is that we are talking about kids. Kids are easily distracted. Between text messaging friends, e-mailing parents, and talking on the phone with girlfriends, college players have a lot to think about. Coaches sometimes try to minimize this, but you try taking a cell phone away from a teenager. In terms of distractions, you also have to remember that we are still talking about students who have to worry about tests and term papers.

    All in all, there are many dynamics working against teams on the road. Add to that the fact that there is not very much separation in terms of talent, and home-field advantage in college sports becomes bigger than any other level of competition.

  • BCS championship hopefuls

    Unpredictability is the only thing predictable about college football.

    With that in mind, it was a strange weekend, as all the top teams were victorious. Texas continued their strong run through a tough Big 12. Penn State won what should amount to the Big Ten title game. USC won in unconvincing fashion. Georgia and Texas Tech both staked their claim as national title contenders.

    Since no landmark victories or major upsets occurred, I am going to take this time to look at the teams still alive in the hunt for the BCS Championship Game.

    Team: Texas (8-0, 4-0 Big 12)
    BCS rank: 1
    Likelihood of reaching the title game: Excellent.
    I expect Texas will beat Texas Tech next weekend and play in the BCS Championship Game.

    Team: Alabama (8-0, 5-0 SEC)
    BCS rank: 2
    Likelihood of reaching the title game: Very good.
    If they win out, they are in. However, Alabama has been playing close games lately. Personally, I do not think the Tide will make it through the season undefeated.

    Team: Penn State (9-0, 5-0 Big Ten)
    BCS rank: 3
    Likelihood of reaching the title game: Excellent.
    They have a large lead over the next team in the BCS. I expect that they will win their remaining games and play for a national championship. Now, whether they deserve to is another question.

    Team: Oklahoma (7-1, 3-1 Big 12)
    BCS rank: 4
    Likelihood of reaching the title game: Almost zero.
    The Sooners would need to win out and have Texas lose two Big 12 games just to make the Big 12 championship game.

    Team: USC (6-1, 4-1 Pac-10)
    BCS rank: 5
    Likelihood of reaching the title game: Almost zero.
    Even though USC won this week, it dropped in both human polls. Add to that the fact that the Trojans' remaining schedule is as soft as cookie dough, and they need a lot of help from other teams. This is actually a good sign, as a one-loss Pac-10 team does not deserve to play for a national championship.

    Team: Georgia (7-1, 4-1 SEC)
    BCS rank: 6
    Likelihood of reaching the title game: Mediocre.
    First, Georgia must win out. Second, it needs either Texas or Penn State to falter. Third, it cannot have Texas Tech go undefeated.

    Team: Texas Tech (8-0, 4-0 Big 12)
    BCS rank: 7
    Likelihood of reaching the title game: Good.
    It’s all in the Red Raiders' hands. If they run the table, their combination of human and computer rankings should put them in the championship game.

    Team: Florida (6-1, 4-1 SEC)
    BCS rank: 8
    Likelihood of reaching the title game: Mediocre. (See Georgia.)
    So that’s it. Four weeks to go in the regular season, plus conference championship games, and only eight teams have a legitimate shot at playing in the BCS Championship Game. This is why I would prefer a four- or eight-team playoff.

    Games of the week:
    No. 1 Texas 28
    No. 7 Oklahoma State 24

    Third-down conversion rates tell the story of this game. Oklahoma State was 5-of-12 while Texas was 11-of-14. Oklahoma State just could not make stops when it counted. The bigger story is that we found out Oklahoma State is as good as their record (now 7-1) indicates.

    They went into Austin, Texas, and competed all day on both sides of the ball. On offense, the Cowboys passed for 200 yards and rushed for another 200. Meanwhile, their defense held Texas to 28 points, their lowest output of the season. This game proves that Oklahoma State is capable of playing with the best teams in the Big 12.

    For a Texas schedule riddled with land mines, this game was just another safe step for the Longhorns. Texas' offense reminds me of the New England Patriots last season. No matter where it starts on the field, the Longhorns can drive for a touchdown.

    Texas’ last three games have all been against teams ranked No. 11 or higher. Over those three games, the Longhorns have an amazing 10 touchdown drives of at least 80 yards. They have not been scoring quickly, but their efficient offense has been very difficult to stop.

    No. 3 Penn State 13
    No. 10 Ohio State 6
    Since the Big Ten does not have a championship game, this game is the de facto conference championship. Penn State entered the game with an 0-7 record at the Horseshoe since joining the Big Ten in 1993. Incredibly, Penn State did not score more than 10 points in any of those seven games. However, they avenged those past demons with a victory this weekend.

    Penn State and Ohio State generally run slightly more open offenses. However, both teams were much more conservative in this game. They did not challenge the defenses with long throws. Instead, both teams opted for running the ball and throwing short passes. This game was the type of smashmouth football that the Big Ten is famous for. After watching a day of shotgun spread attacks, it was nice to see two teams utilize more conventional offenses.

    In the end, a fourth-quarter fumble by Buckeye quarterback Terrelle Pryor led to the only touchdown in the game. This win sets Penn State up for a possible national championship run. When all the dust clears, I expect that Penn will be playing in the BCS title game.

    No. 9 Georgia 52
    No. 11 LSU 38
    I have to admit, I expected more of a defensive struggle. This score was certainly surprising. Georgia and LSU combined for 940 yards, including seven plays over 40 yards. Both offenses moved the ball very well. The difference was that Georgia intercepted LSU three times, returning two for touchdowns.

    This was a huge win for Georgia. They entered the season as the top-ranked team, but their much-hyped offense has sputtered against tough competition. Georgia quarterback Matthew Stafford has been particularly suspect. He came into the season as a Heisman Trophy candidate, but has had difficulty, throwing five interceptions over the previous three games. However, the offense may be starting to get on track, because they looked dominant against LSU.

    Unfortunately, Florida also hung 50 points on LSU, so I am not sure what this game means in regards to Georgia’s offense. Next week’s showdown at home against Florida will establish who the best team in the SEC East really is. If Georgia’s offense is really ready for prime time, then the Bulldogs are capable of running the table and playing for a national title.

    No. 8 Texas Tech 63
    No. 19 Kansas 21
    The Texas Tech Red Raiders entered this game having lost nine straight road games against ranked teams. This stat ended in a big way as Texas Tech completely overwhelmed Kansas in Lawrence, Kan. The Jayhawks could not slow down, let alone stop, Tech’s offense.

    Tech quarterback Graham Harrell left after three quarters with 386 yards, five touchdowns and a 56-14 lead. While they have a good offense, Kansas’s defense is just not good enough to stop the better teams in the Big 12. The last two weeks, both Oklahoma and Texas Tech scored at will against them.

    On the other hand, Texas Tech is a very interesting story this year. Red Raiders coach Mike Leach has proven that his teams can put up points. He has been running the spread offense since before it was popular. However, this seems to be the first year that Tech is being taken seriously on a national scale. I can’t help but think this is because Tech’s once “trick” offense is now commonplace among top teams.

    In any event, Texas Tech is now 8-0 and looking very strong. The Red Raiders' next three games are against the heart of the Big 12, but they are fortunate to have two of them at home. Next week, they play a prime-time game, at home, against Texas. This is turning into a big interstate rivalry game. We know that Tech can score. The question is: Can they contain Texas’ offense?

    Play of the week
    This isn’t exactly a play. However, this week I noticed that on several occasions, kickoff returners let the ball bounce instead of catching it in the air. Let me be clear, I am only talking about kickoffs, not punts. I am also not talking about squib kicks or short kicks to one of the up-men. I am referring only to booming kickoffs.

    For instance, in the Texas Tech-Kansas game, the first three kickoffs hit the ground inside the 10-yard line. It seemed like every game I watched had a booming kickoff hit the turf. I cannot even offer an explanation, as this should never happen. On long kickoffs, there is absolutely no need to worry about getting tackled immediately, so the returner should always catch the ball in the air.

    Letting a kickoff bounce is a recipe for disaster, as was the case several times this past weekend. Once the ball hits the ground, there is no telling where it will go. During the Penn State-Ohio State game, Penn State let a kickoff hit the ground, and the returner ended up picking the ball up at the one with very little place to run. I could practically hear the special teams coaches screaming from my living room.
     
    Things we learned this week
    • Oklahoma State is worthy of a top 10 ranking.
    • The Big East does not deserve a BCS bowl team this year. They currently have only one team ranked in the AP Top 25, and South Florida is overrated at 24.
    • The state of Washington is just bad, as their only two FBS teams, Washington and Washington State, are now a combined 0-14 against FBS opponents.

    Closing thoughts
    I think that, as a whole, college football broadcasts are excellent. You might think that all the best announcers would work for the NFL, but they don’t. I am not going to call out specific people, but I feel that the level of college football announcing is excellent, especially considering the incredibly high number of games each week. You expect good announcing for big-time games, but even minor games are well done.

    In addition to the announcing, I also feel that the camera work is terrific. I imagine football can be a difficult game to broadcast because it's impossible to show the entire field in one shot. Camera crews need to know who has the ball, be in the correct position, and move in for close-ups. Again, with the high volume of college football games broadcast each week, both the announcing and the camera work are terrific.

    One other aspect I love about watching college football is that there are significantly fewer commercials than in a NFL game. I would imagine this is because there are so many games that sponsors will not pay as much for commercials. However, whatever the reason, games are much more enjoyable when the broadcast isn’t cutting out every minute to try and cram as many commercials as possible.

  • Longhorns a notch above

    It felt an awful lot like statement Saturday as teams started to show their true colors against tough conference foes. Some teams stepped up to the challenge while others faltered. Texas proved that last week’s victory over Oklahoma was no fluke, and is now clearly the team to beat. Alabama and Penn State also demonstrated that they are dominant teams.

    After eight weeks, Texas, Alabama and Penn State have separated themselves from the pack. However, the season has a very long way to go. Penn State has their big test next week when they go to the Horseshoe to play Ohio State. Alabama has several tough SEC games remaining. Texas, meanwhile, has a murderous schedule. They still have to play No. 6 Oklahoma State, at No. 8 Texas Tech, at No. 23 Kansas and a Big 12 Championship game, if they get there. If Texas goes undefeated, it would be one of the greatest single seasons in college football history. Obviously, they have a long way to go. If any of these teams slip up, there are a slew of teams who could end up at the top of the rankings.

    Games of the week:
    No. 1 Texas 56
    No. 11 Missouri 31
    I was excited for what I expected to be a marquee matchup of two championship-worthy teams. I suppose this description is kind of true, as Texas is in the hunt for a national championship and Missouri is still in the hunt for a Big 12 North championship -- smaller trophies.

    After last week’s huge victory over then No. 1 Oklahoma, Texas coach Mack Brown had his team dig a hole near their practice field and they buried the game ball. The players received the message loud and clear, because after they buried the ball, they buried Missouri. The final score is not indicative of just how dominant Texas was in this game. The Longhorns' offense scored touchdowns on all five of their first half possessions. Meanwhile, their defense suffocated Missouri’s offense. The Tigers entered the game having gone three-and-out only twice all season. In this game, Texas forced Missouri into three three-and-outs on their first four possessions. At the half, Missouri had only 100 yards of total offense, compared to 352 for Texas.

    So how good is Missouri? After beating up on the likes of Nevada and Buffalo, it has lost at home to Oklahoma State and been beaten badly by Texas. Over the past two weeks, the Tigers' offense has looked nothing like the powerhouse we saw early in the season. Chase Daniel continues to look frustrated against good defenses. Missouri has three tough games on their schedule, and is 1-2 in conference so far. Look for them to win out before a season- ending battle against Kansas, with the Big 12 North crown on the line.

    No. 20 Alabama 24
    Mississippi 20

    I told you that the SEC has many good teams. Alabama was in control at the half. In the second half, its offense fell apart, and Ole Miss began moving the ball. If this game had lasted a little longer, Mississippi might have pulled off the upset. But the Tide were able to hold on, which is what good teams do.

    No. 4 Oklahoma 45
    No. 16 Kansas 31

    It was a record-setting day for both offenses. Oklahoma quarterback Sam Bradford continues to put up silly numbers, as he passed for a school record 468 yards, throwing for three touchdowns and no picks. He hooked up with senior wide receiver Juaquin Inglesias for 12 receptions and 191 yards, both school records. Inglesias was actually outdone by Kansas sophomore wideout Dezmon Briscoe, who caught 12 passes of his own for an amazing 269 yards -- both Kansas school records.

    The Sooners have allowed 962 yards of offense the last two games, but they came together in the second half, forcing Kansas to punt on five straight possessions.

    No. 9 BYU 7
    TCU 32

    Playing at home, TCU dominated BYU, scoring on six of their first seven possessions. On defense, TCU pressured BYU quarterback Max Hall all game, sacking him six times.

    Mid-major programs such as BYU, Utah, and Boise State enter the season knowing they have to go undefeated to even have a chance at a BCS bowl. TCU already lost to Oklahoma. Now they beat BYU to end their dreams of a BCS bowl. In my eyes, this game just shows how good the top of the Mountain West is. Utah, TCU, and BYU are three very good teams that will beat up on each other all season. The Mountain West conference does not get the attention they should.

    No. 10 Georgia 24
    No. 22 Vanderbilt 14
    Georgia’s defense was very good in this one. The Bulldogs picked off two passes and dropped several other would-be interceptions. Neither of these teams looked very good. Georgia started the season No. 1 in the country, but has not played anything like it. The next two weeks, Georgia plays at LSU and at home against Florida. I think they are going to have a tough time in both of these games.

    No. 12 Ohio State 45
    No. 20 Michigan State 7
    And then there were two, as in only two good teams in the Big Ten. Year after year, Michigan State continues to show that it is not able to stand toe-to-toe with the big boys. The Spartans' six consecutive wins prove that they are a good team. However, on Saturday, a very good Ohio State team put them in their place. The Buckeyes led 28-0 at the half, before coasting to victory. Quarterback Terrelle Pryor looked terrific until he was taken out after the game was in hand. Ohio State’s defense was successful because it was able to contain Michigan State running back Javon Ringer, holding him to only 67 yards. In doing so, the Buckeyes forced the Spartans into five turnovers and six punts. Ohio State has looked terrific with Pryor at quarterback. They look like a completely different team than the one that lost badly at USC.

    On a side note, how did I not know that star Ohio State linebacker James Laurinaitis' father is Animal from the WWF tag-team wrestling team Legion of Doom?

    No. 13 LSU 24
    South Carolina 17

    South Carolina led 17-10 at the half and had a 227-189 advantage in total yards. In the second half, LSU held South Carolina to a mere 38 yards and forced two turnovers. Again, any win in the SEC is a good one. I am excited to see how LSU fares next week against Georgia, in what I expect to be a very hard-fought game.

    Play of the week:
    Normally, the play of the week is the best play of the week. However, this week the play is a bad one. In Dabo Swinney’s coaching debut at Clemson, the team ran way too many “trick” plays. This culminated in an absolutely ridiculous double lateral play in the fourth quarter. The play was reminiscent of one used when a team is trailing by a touchdown with only a few second to go, and they try to keep lateraling until they score. The problem with Clemson’s version was that it occurred with three minutes to go in the game. At some point, you need to be able to line up and simply beat the man in front of you. Clemson never seemed to do this.

    Things we learned this week:
    • Texas is clearly the team to beat this year.
    • After two straight losses, Missouri is not ready for prime time.
    • Penn State and Ohio State are the class of the Big Ten.

    Closing thoughts:
    I love the history of the college football bowl system. I also love the fact that so many teams get to play one final game, most of them nationally televised. However, until college football gets some sort of playoff system, they will not have a true national champion.

    BCS rankings come out this week. Now, I am not going to go complain about the initial rankings because there is still so much football to play. I imagine that I will have something to say later in the year. With that said, I can talk about the BCS as a whole. According to the NCAA, the main objective of the BCS is “to match the two top-rated teams in a national championship game.” To this end, it is impossible for the BCS to fail, since the two top-ranked teams automatically play. The main goal of the BCS is not to have the two best teams, or the two most deserving teams play for the championship. No, the goal is to have the two top-rated teams play. So, the obvious next question is how the BCS ranks teams. Come on, you don’t really think the NCAA is going to tell us that, do you?

    The current BCS rankings are based on the results of six computer rankings and two human polls. The two human polls are the Harris and USA Today/Coaches Polls. The Harris Poll is comprised of former players, coaches and administrators. You can go online to get a complete list of the individual participants. The Harris Poll even releases the final week’s individual rankings. It would be nice to have these every week, but at least the final rankings are a start. This season the USA Today/Coaches Poll is made up of 61 current college football head coaches. While a list of coaches is available, their individual rankings are not. Wouldn’t it be nice to know if coaches are ranking teams from their conference higher to help themselves? A better question is: Who actually fills out these rankings? In the past, head coaches wouldn’t even see the rankings -- assistants would create them. However, now that they are part of the BCS, head coaches may actually be involved.

    So far we have one (Harris) poll that has good intentions and one (USA) that is so wrought with possible land mines that I cannot even begin to offer an explanation of how it could be legitimate.

    The six computer rankings are exactly what they sound like. Someone writes a program, inputs the data, and a result is spit out. If this was an accurate way of ranking teams, why would anyone even play sports? Again, the public is not given these formulas or programs, because the writers want sole possession so they can make money. I know that some of the individuals who created these formulas are brilliant mathematicians, but these are just numbers in a computer. I like the idea of using statistics when it comes to in-game decision making, but not when determining if one team is better than another.

    So, the NCAA championship game is selected by former players and coaches; current coaches, whose individual results are not provided; and computer programs, whose formulas are not given. Come on, it’s not like we are launching nuclear weapons here. Shouldn’t the public be allowed to know how these teams are selected? Last year, the BCS rankings came out for the final eight weeks of the season. Over that span, the top two teams changed seven times. That sounds more like a game of musical chairs than a process for selecting the national championship game -- sorry BCS championship game.

    In reality, the BCS is nothing more than a publicity stunt. Its real purpose is to ensure that big- time college football programs make as much money as possible. Did you know that it is impossible for more than one school (Notre Dame excluded) outside of a “big six” conference to make a BCS bowl in a single year? Yes, impossible. Put another way, if the season ended today, Utah, Boise State and TCU would all be eligible for a BCS bowl, and millions of dollars in revenue. However, only Utah would go, since they are ranked highest in the BCS.

  • Rivalries recapped

    On Saturday morning, I was giddy looking forward to games like Oklahoma-Texas, LSU-Florida and Missouri-Oklahoma State. Conference battles and long rivalries are what college football is all about. 

    Most college players will never play professionally, so they don’t have to worry about scouts. College kids play for themselves and their communities. This is why it is so important to beat conference and in-state rivals. Who cares if you beat a team you rarely see? The real treat is when you beat a team whose school is close to you, whose players you know from high school. Then, players can hold their heads high when they go back home and coaches can brag when they go to recruit high school players: “Sure, you could go to Northern Mass next year, but you do know we beat them by twenty points this year, don’t you?”

    After only half a season, the Big 12 and SEC have clearly separated themselves as the two top conferences. Right now, I say we make it official that the winners of the Big 12 and SEC Championship games play for the national title. This way we don't have to worry about what Penn State or USC do the rest of the way.  No disrespect to those teams, but SEC and Big 12 schools have the toughest schedules in the land. Anyone can get up for two big games over the course of the season. It is much more impressive when you have to really focus every week.

    Games of the week
    (1) Oklahoma 35
    (5) Texas 45

    Usually, I am not too worried if I miss the first few minutes of the noon games because there are no marquee matchups. This weekend was an obvious exception as the game of the day started at noon. Oklahoma-Texas is one of the only rivalry games left in country that is truly played on a neutral field. The Cotton Bowl is always evenly divided by fans sporting Texas Orange and Oklahoma Red.

    These two offenses entered the game unchallenged on the season, and both of the highly touted quarterbacks proved their worth. Oklahoma’s Sam Bradford threw for 387 yards and five touchdowns in the loss. Meanwhile, Texas’s Colt McCoy threw for 277 yards and one touchdown – numbers that do not show just how effective he was. It was amazing to watch both quarterbacks pick apart these defenses all game long. The 80 points scored were no fluke. The two offenses are definitely that good.

    But the Longhorns made the big plays in the fourth quarter for a huge victory. These are the kind of games Texas coach Mack Brown used to be infamous for losing. The Longhorns will be ranked No. 1 headed into next week’s show down against Missouri. Let’s see how they do as the hunted ones.

    (3) Missouri 23
    (17) Oklahoma State 28

    Oklahoma State entered the game with five impressive victories. However, since all the wins were against sub-par competition, I really had no idea how good they were. This game proved the Cowboys have enough talent and athleticism to stand toe-to-toe with the best teams in the Big 12. 

    What’s great about the Big 12 is each team gets to prove their worth over the course of the season. Time will tell just how good Oklahoma State is, as they still have to play at Texas, at Texas Tech, and against Oklahoma.

    Oklahoma State’s defense was the story of this game. Playing on the road against a powerful Missouri offense, the Cowboys defense was more aggressive and yet more patient than the Tigers.  They pressured Missouri quarterback Chase Daniel, but did not overcommit with their secondary. And as a result, Daniel looked rushed and flustered all game. He threw three interceptions and made several more poor decisions. 

    Part of the blame has to be pointed at a Missouri coaching staff that simply asks Daniel to do too much. He either passed or rushed the ball on 59 of Missouri’s 70 plays. That is a lot to ask of any quarterback

    (4) LSU 21
    (11) Florida 51
    Florida is a team that can beat anyone. In the Swamp on Saturday night, they destroyed the supposedly best team in the SEC.

    LSU did not pick up a first down until the second quarter. By that time, the Gators were already ahead 17-0. The Tigers did make a run as they bookended halftime with two touchdown drives, but Florida then scored three straight touchdowns to put the game out of reach.

    The key to the Gators' victory was their front seven. After allowing 141 and 140 rushing yards the previous two games, they held LSU to 80 yards rushing and pressured the Tigers two quarterbacks all night. 

    On the offensive side, Florida had everything working. I cannot recall a recent game in which the LSU defense had so much trouble. They could not even slow down the Gators offense, let alone stop them.

    (13) Vanderbilt 14
    Mississippi State 17

    Last week, I mentioned that Vanderbilt was ranked at or near the bottom of the SEC in several key statistical categories, showing that their 5-0 record belied the stats. Mississippi State corrected this error by defeating the Commodores, as they held Vanderbilt to a measly 107 yards of total offense.

    Play of the week
    I am a huge fan of the hook-and-lateral, a play in which one receiver runs a short stop route, catches the ball, and then laterals to a teammate running by. In the midst of a blowout loss, LSU gave Florida coach Urban Meyer some of his own medicine. (Meyer ran the hook-and-lateral play several times while coaching at Utah.) 

    I have to apologize in advance for the play description, as this is a rather complicated play. I searched in vain to find a video clip of this play.

    Facing second-and-2 at the Florida 21-yard line, with under a minute to go in the first half, LSU lined up in the shotgun, with two receivers flanked to each side. Tigers track star/running back Trindon Holliday was lined up in the backfield. Before the snap, one of the wide receivers flanked to the left motioned to the backfield. 

    After the ball was snapped, LSU quarterback Jarrett Lee faked an inside handoff to the wide receiver. Lee then quickly threw a short pass to the one receiver remaining on the left side – Brandon LaFell

    I anticipated a receiver screen, as I noticed the left guard and left tackle ran out wide to block. However, as the ball was being thrown to LaFell, Holliday ran a wheel route, overlapping the receiver. 

    After LaFell caught the ball, he tossed a lateral to Holliday, who picked up about 15 yards down the sideline.

    What is so cool about this play is that wide receiver screens are very common now, so this subtle wrinkle is brilliant. The best part of the play is that, as the throw went to the wide receiver LaFell, the pulling offensive tackle ran wider than the receiver, in order to set up a wall for Holliday.

    Things we learned this week
    • The Big 12 and the SEC are clearly the two top conferences in college football.
    • Joe Paterno has something special with this season’s Penn State team.
    • Spread offenses are still miles ahead of top defenses.

    Closing thoughts
    The theme of this week’s closing thoughts section is: “Quick, let’s fire someone before I get fired.” 

    At Auburn, head coach Tommy Tuberville oversees a very good defense. The offense, however, is another story. Coach Tuberville has run through five offense coordinators in his 10 years at Auburn. 

    After last season’s poor offense performance, Tuberville fired offensive coordinator Al Borges (excuse me, Borges actually “quit”). Tuberville then hired Tony Franklin, who is considered a spread offense guru (just ask him).

    High school players and coaches may recognize his name, since he created “The Tony Franklin System Seminar”, an offensive system based on the spread offense. (Note: when Franklin accepted the job at Auburn, he had to sell his system, which now operates under the name “The System Seminars.” If you are interested, here is the current web site: http://thesystemclinics.com.)

    Last week, after only six games, Tuberville fired Tony Franklin. Sure, Auburn’s offense was playing poorly, but firing someone after six games is completely crazy. To me, this firing is nothing more than coach Tuberville trying to direct the blame away from himself. By firing the offensive coordinator, Tuberville is shifting the failure away from the head coach.

    Personally, I think that Tuberville is a terrific defensive coach. However, he is playing with fire here. If coordinators get fired after one (or half) a bad season, then why should the head coach get to keep his job after a bad season?

  • High-flying Big 12

    So far this season, the elite teams from the Big 12 conference have been scoring at will. You might know that the Big 12 currently boasts four of the top seven teams in the country. What you probably did not realize is that the conference also owns four of the nation’s top six passing offenses, and seven of the top twenty. I wonder what Tom Osborne thinks of this?

    Obviously, these statistics are skewed because of the level of competition. Teams like Chattanooga, Southeast Missouri State and Eastern Washington don’t exactly strike fear into the hearts of these teams. However, the fact is that the Big 12 is racking up huge amounts of yardage and points (six of the top nine scoring teams in the country). The Big 12 has six teams averaging over 43 points per game.

    Now that conference play has started, things are certainly going to get more interesting. The question is: Will these teams continue to rack up points, or will they be stymied by better defenses?

    Games of the week:
    No. 9 USC 44, No. 23 Oregon 10
    With a tough loss last week, USC was sure to have a good game this week. After a slow first quarter, USC picked up their play dramatically and rolled to a blowout victory. When it was all over, the Trojans had produced 598 yards of total offense and scored the game’s final 41 points. During one stretch, USC scored on six consecutive possessions.

    This game proves that USC is still the team to beat in the Pac-10. As for Oregon, they really did not have a chance in this one. Starting your third-string quarterback and playing at the Coliseum against an angry USC team is not a recipe for success.

    Pittsburgh 26, No. 10 South Florida 21
    What a difference a week makes. Pitt played very poorly in their win versus Syracuse last week. Meanwhile, South Florida looked great in a win at North Carolina State. But in Tampa last Thursday, they both looked like completely different teams. Pittsburgh used a smothering defense to upset the No. 10 team in the country. The Panthers held South Florida to 245 yards of total offense, which is over 200 yards below its average. Pittsburgh constantly brought pressure, and USF’s junior quarterback Matt Grothe looked frustrated all night. This game proves that the Big East does not have a team this year that can challenge for the national title.

    No. 19 Vanderbilt 14, No. 13 Auburn 13
    While fans in Ann Arbor can already see some progress with Michigan’s new spread offense, Auburn’s version of the spread still has a long way to go. Auburn managed a measly 208 yards of total offense on the road at Vanderbilt. After a first quarter which saw Auburn score all 13 of its points, the War Eagle's then had to punt on nine consecutive possessions.

    Vanderbilt’s offense wasn’t much better, but it didn’t have to be. The Commodores are 5-0, and I am excited for them. I love when a regular cellar dweller is able to rise up. However, I have to point out that Vanderbilt is winning games with smoke and mirrors. See below for Vandy’s ranking among the twelve teams in the SEC.

    CATEGORY/SEC RANK
    Passing yards per game: 12th
    Rushing yards per game: 3rd
    Passing yards allowed per game: 10th
    Rushing yards allowed per game: 10th

    How are they winning games, you ask? The answer is turnovers. Vanderbilt leads the nation with a +1.8 turnover margin per game. Turnovers can be the golden goose for a football team. The problem is that you can’t count on them. At some point, Vanderbilt is going to have to start plugging the holes in their defense and start creating offense on their own.

    No. 14 Ohio State 20, No. 18 Wisconsin 17
    For 53 minutes and 29 seconds, the Wisconsin defense made Ohio State quarterback Terrelle Pryor look like the true freshman he is. What they couldn’t do was stop him when it counted the most. The Buckeyes drove 80 yards in the waning minutes for a go-ahead touchdown. On the final drive, Pryor threw for 59 yards before scoring on an 11-yard run. With Pryor running the offense and a relatively healthy Beanie Wells in the backfield, Ohio State is a very formidable team. I bet they would love another shot at USC with this squad.

    Wisconsin let a game slip away that they really needed to have in order to vie for the Big Ten crown. After blowing a big halftime lead against Michigan last week, Wisconsin is now 0-2 in the conference. Next week against Penn State will define which direction their season is going. A loss to the Nittany Lions would all but end any chance the Badgers have of winning the Big Ten.

    Hawaii 32, No. 22 Fresno State 29
    Fresno State simply did not come to play in this one. They reminded me of Wile E. Coyote, standing dumbfounded as an Acme missile hurls itself in his direction. Fresno State committed six turnovers, missed three field goals and still took the game to overtime. However, OT was more of the same, as Fresno missed a field goal before Hawaii finally put the game away.

    Fresno State is never able to put together a complete season. I think the main reason for this is that they try to stack their schedule. I believe this really wears on the players. This was only the fifth game, but already the Bulldogs have played a Big East team, a Big Ten team and a Pac-10 team. Meanwhile, many of these big-time programs load up with cupcakes before starting their conference play.

    Play of the week
    After an Alabama punt in the third quarter, Kentucky started with the ball at its own 30. To that point, Kentucky had managed only 73 yards of offense. After a ‘Bama penalty, Kentucky completed a wide receiver bubble screen for 36 yards. On the very next play, Kentucky ran the same play to the opposite side. This wide receiver bubble screen resulted in a 26-yard touchdown pass.

    The first screen was a good call because Alabama was regularly sending extra men. The second screen was an even better call. Sometimes you just need to go with what works. You see this all the time in high school football, where coaches have much smaller playbooks. College coaches often try to outthink the opponent, when the most obvious answer is often the correct one.

    Things we learned this week:
    • The Big 12 offenses are deadly.
    • With UConn and South Florida both losing, the Big East is in bad shape.
    • After some good preseason hype and a solid start, Arizona State looks like it is in disarray.

    Closing thoughts
    Why do teams bring in the “BIG” formation on short yardage situations in the middle of the field? Big formations are referred to as “goal-line” sets. This is because they are best suited for use on the goal line, where the end zone is only 10 yards deep and linebackers and safeties are right behind the line of scrimmage. End zones are only 10 yards deep in order to make it more difficult for offenses to gain yardage when points are on the line.

    By using a "BIG" set in the middle of the field, an offense is allowing the defense to treat it as a goal line situation, which is playing right into their hands. Even if teams throw out of this set, all of the players are crowded around the line of scrimmage to begin with. This gives a huge, yet unnecessary, advantage to the defense.

    The use of a "BIG" set in middle-of-the-field short yardage situations is even more confounding when the offense normally features a spread system. I am perplexed why a team that runs the spread offense would all of a sudden use a goal-line set on fourth-and-one at the opponent’s 40-yard line. It takes a different type of mentality to put nine guys on the line of scrimmage and try to plow ahead for one yard. Teams that run the spread offense, with the quarterbacks constantly in the shotgun, are not used to playing smashmouth football. The offensive linemen often line up in a squatting stance and create multiple running lanes. It i